Juizo Verdadeiro sobre a carta contra os Medicos, Cirurgioens e Boticarios

(5 User reviews)   1091
Morganti, Bento, 1709- Morganti, Bento, 1709-
Portuguese
Okay, picture this: It's 1709, and someone in Portugal has just published a scathing public letter attacking all the doctors, surgeons, and apothecaries. The medical community is furious. Enter Bento Morganti, a man with a quill and an opinion. This book is his fiery, point-by-point takedown of that letter. It's not a dry medical text; it's a full-blown public feud in book form. Think of it as an 18th-century Twitter thread, but with way better grammar and actual stakes. It's a fascinating glimpse into a time when medical debates were settled in print, not peer-reviewed journals. If you've ever wanted to be a fly on the wall during a massive professional drama from 300 years ago, this is your chance.
Share

Read "Juizo Verdadeiro sobre a carta contra os Medicos, Cirurgioens e Boticarios" Online

This book is available in the public domain. Start reading the digital edition below.

START READING FULL BOOK
Instant Access    Mobile Friendly

Book Preview

A short preview of the book’s content is shown below to give you an idea of its style and themes.

Illustrations have been moved so they do not break up paragraphs. Old or antiquated spellings have been preserved. Typographical and punctuation errors have been silently corrected. [Illustration] Fotoset and Lithographed by COLORTONE PRESS, Washington 9, D. C. ARMS AND ARMOR OF THE PILGRIMS 1620-1692 by Harold L. Peterson [Illustration: Patrero or “murderer”] Published by Plimoth Plantation, Inc. and the Pilgrim Society, Plymouth 1957 [Illustration: _A seventeenth century musketeer ready to fire his matchlock. From Jacques de Gheyn_, Maniement d’Armes, _1608_.] The average colonist landing on the wild shores of North America in the early 1600’s set great store by his arms and armor. The Pilgrims were no exception. They were strangers in a vast and largely unknown land, inhabited by wild beasts and peopled by savages who were frequently hostile. Greatly outnumbered by known enemies and possibly facing dangers of which they were not yet aware, these Englishmen placed their main hope for survival on the possession of superior weapons and protective armor. On the more peaceful side, their firearms were also valuable, for they provided fresh meat for the table and furs for sale back home. Because the colonist was so dependent on his arms he soon learned to select the most efficient kinds that he could obtain. In so doing he pushed the evolution of military materiel far ahead of contemporary Europe and developed a high degree of skill, particularly in the use of firearms. The military supplies which the Pilgrims brought with them may be divided into three major categories: defensive armor, edged weapons, and projectile weapons. A completely armed man, especially in the first years, was usually equipped with one or more articles from each of the three groups, usually a helmet and corselet, a sword, and a musket. ARMOR Of all the pieces of defensive armor, the most popular was the helmet. Almost everyone wore one when he prepared for trouble. Most of those worn at Plymouth were undoubtedly open helmets which left the face uncovered, although it is possible that a few completely closed helmets were also used. These open helmets were of three principal types: the cabasset, the morion, and the burgonet. The cabasset was a simple, narrow brimmed helmet with a keeled bowl and a tiny apical peak pointing to the rear. The morion had a larger crescentic brim pointed at the front and back and a high comb along the center-line of the bowl. The better specimens of both these helmets were forged from a single billet of steel, and both were very efficient defenses. The curving lines of the bowls caused most blows to glance off without imparting their full impact, and the comb of the morion presented an extra buffer of metal through which a sword would have to cut before it reached the bowl. Inside each helmet was a quilted lining held in place by a row of rivets around the base of the crown which acted much like the modern helmet liner in holding the steel shell away from the wearer’s head. [Illustration: _Cabasset._] [Illustration: _Morion._] The burgonet was a slightly more complicated helmet than the morion or cabasset, and it was made in a variety of styles. Basically, it was an open-faced helmet which covered more of the head than the other two. Usually it had a peak or umbril somewhat like the visor of a modern cap over the eyes, a comb on the bowl, and movable plates to protect the cheeks and ears. Often there was a defense for the face in the form of a single adjustable bar which passed through a hole...

This is a limited preview. Download the book to read the full content.

Published in 1709, this book is Bento Morganti's direct response to a pamphlet that was making the rounds in Portugal, one that harshly criticized the entire medical profession. Morganti steps up to defend the honor and expertise of doctors, surgeons, and pharmacists of his day.

The Story

There isn't a traditional plot with characters. Instead, the "story" is the argument itself. Morganti takes the original critical letter and systematically refutes its claims. He argues for the importance of formal medical training, defends the practices of the time, and likely throws some serious shade at the anonymous author of the original attack. It's a snapshot of a heated public debate about who gets to heal people and how they should do it.

Why You Should Read It

What's amazing is how familiar some of the tensions feel. The public questioning expert authority, debates over who is a "real" professional, and the clash between traditional knowledge and emerging science—it's all here. Reading Morganti's passionate defense, you get a real sense of the personalities involved. This isn't a sterile history; it's a man with skin in the game fighting for his reputation and that of his colleagues.

Final Verdict

This is a niche but utterly captivating read for anyone interested in the history of medicine, science, or just plain old human drama. It's perfect for history buffs who enjoy primary sources that haven't been sanitized, and for anyone who likes seeing how public arguments worked long before the internet. You won't get a neat narrative, but you will get a front-row seat to a 300-year-old professional roast.



🔖 Copyright Free

There are no legal restrictions on this material. It is now common property for all to enjoy.

George Lee
1 month ago

I didn’t realize how engaging this would be until the diagrams and footnotes included in this version are very helpful. I’ll definitely revisit this in the future.

Melissa Allen
3 months ago

I was genuinely impressed since the content encourages further exploration of the subject. I’ll be referencing this again soon.

Oliver Carter
4 months ago

I discovered this unexpectedly and it provides a comprehensive overview that is perfect for students and experts alike. This turned out to be a great decision.

Mary Hall
3 months ago

This stood out immediately because the plot twists are genuinely surprising without feeling cheap or forced. Don't hesitate to download this.

Amanda Nelson
4 months ago

I was skeptical at first, but the translation seems very fluid and captures the original nuance perfectly. Don't hesitate to download this.

4.5
4.5 out of 5 (5 User reviews )

Add a Review

Your Rating *
There are no comments for this eBook.
You must log in to post a comment.
Log in

Related eBooks